Offline · runs in this room
LandIQ
Water security · Lower Indus basin

The Sindh Water Room

More water reaches Sindh than its canals can take. Here is where it arrives, where it escapes to the sea, and what it would take to keep more of it. Measured district by district, from open records.

Prepared byLandIQAli Bin Shahidali@landiq.earth · alibinshahid.earth
ForGovernment of SindhChief Minister's Office
DateJuly 2026Pre-concept map
RunsOfflineNo internet needed in the room

Every figure is computed from public inputs or cited to source. See “The ask” for what is ours and what is not.

Track record

The same methods, already applied across five geographies.

LandIQ (Ali Bin Shahid). Watershed diagnostics, restoration design and water-cycle analysis, from applied work across Colombia, Portugal, Spain, Jordan and the wider Middle East. Every item below is publicly listed and checkable.

Colombia

Buturama Creek

7,238 ha · 128,000 beneficiaries

Riparian and forest restoration. Watershed diagnostics and intervention design.

Portugal

Côa Valley

Head Scientist, Ten Lives rewilding

Mediterranean water-cycle design across the Côa, in Portugal's north-east.

Spain

Maestrazgo

with HOPE! in the Maestrazgo Massif

Dryland water-cycle restoration in the Valencian uplands, a separate landscape from the Côa.

Jordan

Arid-zone, closest analogue to Sindh

Consulting through Green Deck

Arid-zone water stress and soil-moisture regime work in a hot, dry, salinity-prone setting, the nearest match to Sindh's own conditions.

The published record

Gulf and Middle East water security, a strategy paper for the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, with Olivia Lazard: how water shapes security and statecraft across the region.

In Defence of the Biotic Pump (2025), on continental moisture transport: where rain forms before it falls.

19
published works

Portfolio: alibinshahid.earth
ORCID 0009-0003-9709-4241

What 2022 cost

Sindh is not short of water. It lets a year of it run to the sea.

The same province that ran a 50% canal shortfall in 2025 let more water pass Kotri to the sea in 2022-23 than its entire canal system takes in a full year.

Cropland under water, 2022
56.7%
Our own 10 m layer, 29 districts. 58.5% at coarse resolution.
National damage and loss
$30.1bn
$14.9bn damage, $15.2bn loss (2022 PDNA).
Insurance actually paid
$25.3m
Domestically retained claims. In effect, nothing was covered.
42.2MAF
Passed Kotri to the sea, 2022-23
More than Sindh's entire canal system withdraws in a whole year, about 52 km³. Water the province was sent, and let go.
In one lineWater-rich, not water-poor. Keeping it is the opportunity.
Where it landed

Five districts lost almost their entire cropland.

Computed from our own layer at 10 metres: flood extent intersected with cropland, district by district. Not quoted from a report.

Cropland under water, 2022: worst 12 districts

% of district cropland · LandIQ 10 m layer

Each bar is the share of a district's cropland that stood under water in 2022. The five in red lost almost everything. At 10 metres we can show you the field. We cannot show you the house.

Rain does not explain it

Station rainfall: 1991–2020 normal vs 2022 (mm)

White is each station's normal year, red is 2022. Padidan's normal is 108 mm; in 2022 it took 1,764 mm. The monsoon delivered a year of canal supply in ten weeks. Where that water goes next is a design choice, not a weather outcome.

In one lineWe measured this ourselves, and you can check every number.
The arithmetic

The water is sent. The system is built to let it go.

What arrives, what the canals take, and what runs on to the sea unused: three numbers that sit beside each other every year.

Entitlement against actual withdrawals

MAF per water year, 1 MAF ≈ 1.23 km³ · IRSA Annual Report 2024-25

Each bar is one year's canal withdrawals. The dashed line is Sindh's full entitlement of 48.76 MAF (about 60 km³), and every year falls short of it, by about 17% on average. 2022-23 is low because the canals were shut during the flood.

What passed below Kotri

MAF per water year · IRSA

Each bar is the water that reached the sea below Kotri. The dashed line is the 10 MAF (about 12 km³) the Accord set aside for the delta; red bars fall short of it. The delta gets water only in flood years, almost nothing otherwise.

In one lineSindh lets a full year of water run to the sea.
Sent, not allocated

Sindh argues over its allocation while a larger volume runs to the sea.

For decades the case has been about what Sindh was owed under the Accord. The bigger number sits on the other side of the ledger: the water already arriving inside Sindh's own borders, more than the entitlement, running past Kotri to the sea because nothing is built to hold it.

42 MAF to the sea

In 2022-23 more water passed below Kotri, about 52 km³, than Sindh's entire canal system withdraws in a full year (IRSA).

18 km³ ran past uncaptured

In the 2025 flood alone about 18 km³ moved down the upper reach above a moderate harvest cap, and almost none of it was held.

And the volume is rising

Rainfall over Sindh is trending up, with the 2010s about 45% wetter than the 1980s, so what arrives each year is growing, not shrinking.

In one lineThe water is already here. Our only job is to stop letting it leave.
The trend

Every year, more water arrives, not less.

Two things measured from open satellite records: rainfall over Sindh is rising, and Sindh's underground water holds steady while the provinces upstream pump theirs down.

Rainfall over Sindh is rising

Annual total, area-averaged · CHIRPS 0.05°, 1981–2025

Each bar is one year of rainfall. The orange line is the long-run trend, rising 3.1 mm a year. Red is 2022, the wettest year on record. The 2010s were about 45% wetter than the 1980s, and almost all of it falls in four monsoon months.

Stored water: Sindh steady, the basin above it falling

Change in total water storage, cm per year · GRACE / GRACE-FO, CSR mascon

Each bar is one region's change in stored water. Grey is 2002 to 2014, colour is 2015 onward. Bars to the right are gaining water, bars to the left are losing it. Sindh sits on the right and is gaining; Punjab loses 2.64 cm a year. Sindh is not using up its groundwater while the provinces above it are.

In one lineThe water is arriving. Sindh is the one province keeping it.
Three openings

Three openings Sindh can act on before the next season.

Each stands on its own. Each uses records the province already holds, against programmes already funded and running.

Flood screening Reconstruction

1.25 million houses are under construction. Independent verification reaches a 5% sample, and it checks whether a house was built, not whether it should have been built there.

  • Screen a district's reconstruction coordinates against where water actually stood in 2022.
  • Output: a flagged list, a confidence value on every unit, and an honest statement of where the method fails: dense settlement, tree cover, small roofs.
  • You supply coordinates and records. We bring the high-resolution imagery and elevation the job needs.

Water for crops Irrigation

Allocation is measured at the canal head. What reaches the root zone is a different number, and it is the one that decides a season.

  • Where canal water actually arrives, by command and by parcel, not where it was allocated.
  • Standard crop-water accounting against measured conditions, so a shortfall can be located rather than argued about.
  • Re-measured next season, so the province can see whether a change worked.

Salinity Land recovery

Measured soil salinity now exists for the province: median 1.8 dS/m, with 43% of Sindh above 2 dS/m and 0.7% above the 4 dS/m saline threshold. The severe ground is not spread evenly, and it is not idle.

  • 42% of the strongly saline land is under crop. Salt is concentrated on the delta and canal land that is still being farmed, which is exactly where reclamation pays back.
  • Parcel-scale mapping, ranked by recoverable area, where treatment returns the most land per rupee spent.
  • Re-measured the following season to show movement, not just a baseline.
  • Ranking is the product. A map that cannot be acted on in a season is not worth commissioning.
In one linePick one. We start this season, on records you already hold.
2022 flood record
Share of each district's cropland that stood under water.
Guddu BarrageSukkur BarrageKotri Barrage JacobabadLarkanaShikarpurKambar Shahdad KotKashmoreSujawalBadinTando Muhammad KhanDaduNaushahro FerozeShaheed Benazir AbadKhairpurThattaSukkurGhotkiMatiariJamshoroUmer KotHyderabadSangharMirpur KhasTando AllahyarMalir KarachiTharparkarCentral KarachiEast KarachiKorangi KarachiSouth KarachiWest Karachi Arabian Sea
100 km
Districts & flood intersect: LandIQ 10 m layer (UNOSAT 2022 extent × ESA WorldCover)
Rivers: Natural Earth · Canals: © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL)
Two tails, one lever

Flood and drought are the two ends of the same water. One lever answers both.

Sindh's rainfall is swinging harder: the driest year on record held 59 mm, the wettest 473 mm, an eightfold spread, and the wet years now cluster in the last decade. Two problems, one opportunity. The swing has to be buffered, and that is done by placing the right interventions at the trigger points, the few spots where each action carries the furthest.

42.2 MAFran to the sea, 2022-23
18 km³harvestable flood surplus
1 to 3 km³buffers the whole swing
9 in 10under a water hazard
47.7Mpeople it reaches

One lever: catch the peak, release the trough

River inflow to upper Sindh by month, 2025 · km³ · GloFAS (modelled)

The lever is not a single dam but a set of interventions placed where they carry furthest: catchment design, riparian buffers, biochar, partner crops, cyanobacterial inoculation. Catch 1 to 3 km³ of the roughly 18 km³ flood surplus, release it in the dry months, and the swing is buffered. Inflow modelled (GloFAS), used for the shape of the year, not a gauged total.

The same water eases what most of Sindh lives under

53.2M people by number of overlapping water hazards · WorldPop 2020

About nine in ten of Sindh's 53.2 million live under at least one water hazard. Flood, drought and salinity are the three openings, and the same buffered water eases all three. Careful placement does more: it steers recharge clear of arsenic-prone ground and steadies cropland against salt and disease, which is why every intervention is sited by measurement, never by guess.

In one lineBuffered at the right trigger points, one flood answers the drought, the salt, and the next flood together, and steers clear of the arsenic.
Where this leads

A dried channel can run again. What we build it back to sets the scale.

Sindh has channels that once carried water, and the province has already started refilling one with the Dhoro Puran revival. Groundwater can add to that. How far a channel runs comes down to one clear choice, and a living seasonal stream is well within reach of a small slice of the flood.

A living seasonal channel
110 to 330 km
Usable flow and wetlands, from harvesting 1 to 3 km³ a year. That is 1 to 3% of what the river carries past Guddu in a monsoon, and it is the length of the Nara or the Dhoro Puran corridor.
A string of pools
1,100 km
Riparian habitat rather than flow, for 1 km³ a year. Cheap in water, real in ecological terms. It is a living wetland corridor, not a flowing river.
Near-historical discharge
about 10 km
For the same 1 km³. A full river needs roughly a hundred times more water per kilometre. That is a surface-reallocation question, which is exactly what the province's own Dhoro Puran scheme does.

What it would take

Delivering 0.8 km³ a year means on the order of 100,000 recharge wells plus about 2,000 km² of riparian spreading. Three times that reaches 2.25 km³ a year, enough for a functional Nara and a functional Dhoro Puran together. These are scale estimates for a first conversation, not a design.

The constraint that governs all of it

Recharge routes water, it does not create it. Sindh's stored water is already close to flat, so this only works if the water is captured from flood peaks, when the river is in spate, and released back as baseflow in the dry season. In the 2025 flood, about 18 km³ ran through the upper reach above a moderate cap; the 1 to 3 km³ this needs is a small slice of that. Reviving a channel this way is really flood water moved in time, the same operation that lowers flood exposure and flushes salt from the cropland alongside.

First-order scenario arithmetic, not a calibrated groundwater model. Orders of magnitude and the comparison between definitions are robust; the absolute lengths are estimates. A real answer needs aquifer tests, channel-bed survey and a flow model, which is the feasibility stage.

The ask

This is the first map, not the plan.

Everything shown here was built from open records and our own layer, without asking the province for anything. That is deliberate: it is how a first look should arrive. What follows is a sequence, and each step only happens if the one before it produced something worth acting on.

You are here
Pre-concept map
What is visible from outside, at province and district scale.
The commission
Pre-feasibility, all of Sindh
Is it viable, and where. Whole province, because the water is sent from upstream and lost downstream.
Then
Feasibility
Engineering-grade design and cost for the interventions worth building.
Finally
Implementation
Delivered with SIDA and the programmes already funded.
First

The data you already hold

Canal operations, reconstruction and land records, gauge and survey archives. The pre-feasibility begins on what already exists, nothing new to collect to start.

Second

Backing for the ground work

Where the exact picture needs measurement the free data cannot give, backing to fill those gaps on the ground. A district map tells you where to worry; a located one tells you what to do.

Third

A mandate and one focal point

An instruction that this is commissioned, and one named person to work through. The province keeps the data, the method, and the result.

Why the whole province, not one watershed

The lever only reads at province scale: the flood peak arrives from upstream, is held or lost through the canal commands, and what is left reaches the delta and the sea. A single watershed cannot answer whether Sindh can catch the peak and carry the dry season, because the water that matters is sent from above and lost below. The pre-feasibility is province-wide by necessity.

“Commission the first study, for all of Sindh. It tells you what can be kept, where, and what it would take, before any capital moves.”

LandIQ · Ali Bin Shahid · ali@landiq.earth · alibinshahid.earth. The province keeps the data, the method, and the result.

The wider platform

The full build is a live water room for the whole province.

What you have seen is a static demo, computed once from public data. The same platform runs live, and the three areas below sit beside it, already in the maps.

The bigger build

A live water room

A real-time feed of the province's water, the recovery and storage interventions mapped and tracked from proposal to built, and the wider land signals beside them.

Real-time water: rain, river, canal, groundwater, salinity, coast Interventions mapped and tracked, from proposal to built Methane, landfill and livestock, by location
The kind of signal, live · 2025 river-basin rainfall, km³ per month
Water quality

Wetlands that clean the water on the way through

runoff · sewage wetland cleaned

Riparian buffers and constructed wetlands strip nutrient runoff from farmland and settle urban sewage before it reaches the river and delta. The recharge programme already places about 2,000 km² of riparian spreading; on the drainage lines it doubles as treatment.

The coast

Mangroves that hold the delta and slow the salt

−5.8% since 1996

Delta mangroves fell from 667 to 628 km² between 1996 and 2016 as the sea rises about 3.5 mm a year at Karachi. They buffer surge, anchor the fishery, and slow the salt wedge. We map where restoration holds, and where returning captured flood as freshwater lets it recover.

Exploratory

Restoring the land to lift the rain

restore uplands

Ali's published work on the biotic pump: continental moisture is drawn inland by vegetation, so restoring upland and catchment surfaces can strengthen the moisture cycle that forms rain. A long-run, upstream lever, offered as a direction to explore, not a claim.

Every figure in this room traces to one shared master table, auditable line by line, alongside the 2025 monthly hydrograph above. Nothing here is asserted without a source.

Speaker notespress S to hide